Step into history with this beautiful circa 1840 Federal-style home on a desirable street in the Village of Cooperstown. This single-family residence, set on a 0.46-acre lot, boasts over 3,800 square feet of living space, featuring 3 full and 2 half bathrooms. The main level includes a renovated large kitchen that overlooks the backyard. The kitchen has cherry cabinets, radiant heat, and newer stainless steel appliances. French doors lead out to the bluestone patio, providing a perfect blend of indoor and outdoor living. There is a formal dining room for holiday gatherings, and a gas fireplace with built-in bookcases flanked on both sides grace the formal living room. On the second floor, four good-sized bedrooms have ample closet space. The primary bedroom has a new bathroom with a walk-in shower, two closets, and a window seat. One of the bedrooms also features a 1/2 bath. The second-floor laundry room has floor-to-ceiling cupboards for convenience. The basement has been renovated, creating a wonderful additional living space with a new 3/4 bathroom. It is perfect for a private guestroom or ample space for an exercise room, playroom, or home office. Outside awaits an inviting bluestone patio, perfect for relaxing and entertaining, and a large, lush lawn that is meticulously maintained. Some improvements include the home's exterior being freshly painted in 2024, a new side porch in 2021, and a new walkway in 2022. Electricity was updated, and a new commercial-grade furnace was installed in 2018. A new roof was installed in 2014. An easy stroll to Clarks Sports Center, Basset Medical Center, Main Street for shopping and restaurants, and the Baseball Hall Of Fame. Stroll down to Otsego Lake during the warmer months, or take a short drive to Glimmerglass Beach and picnic there, soaking in the beautiful surroundings. You're also just a short walk to the Otesaga Resort and its award-winning golf course that trails along Otsego Lake shores. This property boasts a timeless elegance combined with modern comforts. Don't miss out on this unique opportunity to own a piece of Cooperstown's history. Schedule your private showing today!